H&M eyeliner: a dupe for MAC?

Today I'm comparing two eyeliners from two different brands: MAC and H&M.
It's about the eyeliner Teddy (eye kohl) from Mac and Over The Taupe from H&M. The one from MAC is more warm toned and the one from H&M is more cool toned. They are however very similar in applying (both very buttery smooth) and they both have little flecks of gold in them.

IMG_2889.JPG

On the eyes they look very similar. I applied one eyeliner on one eye and the other on the other eye. I used no primer so you can see how these wore througout the day.

                                      H&M                                                                                                                 MAC

                                      H&M                                                                                                                 MAC

In person, you can see the difference but it isn't that obvious once you've put on your mascara

H&M

H&M

MAC

MAC

I like to apply these as an actual eyeliner because they both don't last very long in the waterline (the MAC one a little longer than the H&M one).

It will stay put all day (even without an eye primer). I rubbed my eyes a lot and it didn't come of (I'm studying and forgot I had something on my eyeballs :p).

After a whole day

After a whole day

I would like to say the H&M liners are a dupe for the MAC eye kohl liners. The pricetag makes all the difference: it's only €4,99 for the H&M liner while the MAC eyeliner has a huge pricetag of €16,5. If you want to treat yourself, you can definitely buy the MAC one, otherwhise, I recommend the H&M eyeliners, they are very good and you can buy 3 for the price of 1 MAC!

The MAC one (in this particular colour) emphasizes the green in my eyes more because it has a more reddish undertone in it compared to the Over The Taupe liner from H&M. That's why I bought it in the first place, still really pleased with this colour!

Do you know good dupes for high end brands?

Talk to you soon,
Emilie